Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | d0m's commentslogin

I wonder which country will be the first to be run entirely by AI instead of corrupt politicians

I don’t think a country where everyone is absolutely right would work.

You're absolutely right.

This makes me think of back when people were really hyped about DAOs because technology was going to solve the problems with squishy, fallible humans.

>I wonder which country will be the first to be run entirely by AI instead of corrupt politicians

State of Utopia[1] has this manifesto[2]. In our estimation (and we use AI a lot), it is not powerful enough to govern a country yet. We thought it was worth trying anyway.[3] We would like it to be able to handle contexts that are millions of times greater (think more like 1 billion tokens than 1 million tokens), and even so AI governance is a very difficult matter. In addition, once AI governance is achieved, how can you truly trust the governance model not to be corrupted? Transparent government run by AI is an additional point of difficulty. These days, the most difficult unsolved problem is how to introduce voting and users' comments without inviting comment spam and vote rigging. You can watch my latest update here[4] (I'm sorry, it's very quiet), and we welcome your input on all subjects. We have a fully autonomous agent currently running the country, which consists of a Mac Mini and a Claude subscription (plus our own dedicated server in a country that recognizes us, and we have a couple of other embassies by agreement and legal contract). But in practice this government just does whatever I tell it. It's not advanced enough to run a code of laws, which is one of the basic requirements citizens expect of their country. The size of problem space for running a country is larger than models can handle, but many things help.

One of the best hopes we have is with deterministic offline models where we share the pipeline with people ahead of time, so they know exactly how it will work. This could be a trustworthy matter of dispute resolution, if we get the architecture right.

For example, our country could help you sign a contract and in case of dispute, both parties could submit supporting documents and make statements and the offline model they agreed to at the time of signing their contract could adjudicate. This pipeline could be transparent from the start. This won't satisfy everyone, but might provide the minimum standard of having a code of laws that assists with contract enforcement. For now, all you can really do is keep checking our site for updates and leave comments about what direction you'd like the country to take. (For example, you can leave a comment on my latest update on Youtube.)

[1] https://stateofutopia.com

[2] https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/d6b35b81-0eeb-4e41-9628-5...

[3] https://medium.com/@rviragh/ai-is-not-ready-to-create-utopia...

[4] https://www.youtube.com/live/K0dgrPRWPCs


Apple/Google could easily make web apps native if they wanted


No, the distinction is that he had the option to remain at YC if he chose to. He could have simply turned down the offer from OpenAI. It's similar to receiving a job offer from another company... you’re not being dismissed from your current job. You get to decide whether you want to stay or move on.


I was thinking about this just the other day. If infinity isn't actually a thing in our universe, then maybe we're taking some risks by using math with all these infinite limits and integers. Maybe if we look at theorems without using infinity, we'd stumble upon new or different equations.


You'd probably enjoy looking into negative infinities, which has been vigorously debated throughout history.


Hands down the best book I've read to level up my UI game. Highly recommended to developers who want to get better at UI design with no bullshit and a lot of practical examples.


Run the Alpaca chat and ask it :)


Personally, I used to be very passionate about coding. but over time I've realized that I'm more excited about products/design and working with great people. I know that going into management is often frowned upon among engineers, but I personally love it because I can continue to work on products without constantly banging my head about compiler errors or annoying bugs. Basically, what I'm trying to say is that it's possible to be passionate about building products without having to sit and code all day.


Very cool! I have such fond memories of The Little Schemer


That landing page is really amazing


I love this. How does it work copyright-wise?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: