Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What is fair compensation for innocent victims put behind bars?

When wrongly convicted inmates are freed from prison, I think it reasonable to remunerate them per year of jail time, with accelerating penalties (as more years are lost to jail, opportunity is taken away at an accelerating rate; 20 years lost to prison is far more than 10 times worse than 2 years lost to prison, for example).

The base rate of $550,000 tax-free per year for lost work/family/life opportunity and pain/suffering seems eminently fair to me, with escalating amounts per year, as stated before. Probably could get behind a permanent waiver of personal income tax for life on any income under $200,000/year as well.



I agree that the victims of false imprisonment deserve a heck of a lot more than they get now, but one thing to consider is that mandating things like this may lead to fewer convictions being overturned due to the costs it would incur. It wouldn't help at all if the requirements just keep more innocent people in prison longer.


It should depend on age: 10 year behind bars for a 18yo destroys more than 10 years for a 65yo.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: