Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Basically all of history. Terrorist is a term people use for people who use violence and intimidation to attempt to cause political change. Freedom fighter is a term used for people who use violence and intimidation to attempt to cause political change that you are sympathetic to.

Both words have identical meanings, the only difference is if you happen to agree with the people commiting the violent acts or not.



> Both words have identical meanings

Only online. The Viet Cong weren’t targeting civilians. They hit American soldiers. Targeting military and narrow political power are the hallmark of proper rebellions. Targeting civilians is how terrorism works.

The closest analog to terrorism in warfare is actually strategic air campaigns. Dresden and the London Blitz are closer to terrorism than e.g. the uprising in Bangladesh or even the Taliban toppling the Karzai regime. And lo and behold, strategic air campaigns have a history of uniting the enemy much more than undoing them.


Generally speaking, people do not use the word terrorism or freedom fighter to describe the actions of a state actor during open war.


> people do not use the word terrorism or freedom fighter to describe the actions of a state actor during open war

People also don’t use the term to relate to rebellions. It’s more an internet meme or cases where like a few people call e.g. Russia a terrorist state by analogy. Freedom fighters fighting rebellion tend to work to keep civilians on their side. When they don’t, they become terrorists and tend to lose.


No, not at all. Methods and targets/victims also matter. Using violence to achieve specific military objectives or as a response to violence is not the same as indiscriminate murder and terrorism.


> as a response to violence

Literally every terrorist group ever claims they are responding to some sort of violence or oppression.


So what? It what they are actually doing that matters.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: