Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


Do you have any proof to back these extraordinary claims?

If you have the faintest idea how "microwave technology" can mechanistically and physiologically read minds, you should explain your understanding.

My undergrad physical chemistry, bio degree, etc. make me question this. Microwave is for rotational spectroscopy. That gives you gas-phase or polar molecules. I assume you mean to say they're reading water? So... Concentrations? Blood flow? Seems incredibly low signal and dangerous.

If this is a joke, (which seems most plausible), this isn't a great manner of discourse for HN. It confuses, wastes mental cycles, and decreases signal:noise. Please think of everyone having to parse this stuff.


My basic understanding of the system:

- Electromagnetic energy (photons) at certain wavelengths will pass though brain tissue (neurons) and interact with them.

- This interaction is dependent on the neuron's polarization state (from a negative voltage (unfired), to a positive one (fired)).

- The cacophony of noise and interactions can be measured and deconvoled to show patterns.

- Groups of neurons and their polarization states can be observed (much like an fMRI scanner deconvolves magnetic impulses to show a 3D image, this system deconvoles microwave radiation from a MASER).

- The microwave carriers (which are in the GHz) operate much faster than your brain (which is KHz at best), so deconvolution and denoising techniques have plenty of data to work with.

- The radiation reflected back is in terabits per second, but your mental processes and sensory inputs are much lower, so there is a million-to-one oversampling of the data (i.e. the information is there, decoding it is key).

Obviously if I had a working system that would be my proof, but that's a widget they won't let me near! I could write volumes about this, but convincing people that it is even possible is difficult. Hopefully the graybeards and smarties out around here can piece it together. I wish I were joking, but that's up to the reader to decide. <:)


>- The cacophony of noise and interactions can be measured and deconvoled to show patterns.

theoretically. On practice we are yet to see.

>The microwave carriers (which are in the GHz) operate much faster than your brain

they also tend to cook various molecules/tissues. Not the whole GHz range of course and not all the molecules/tissues. The issue is to find the frequencies which don't cook anything in the brain at the power level which would still allow for good signal/noise. It sounds like something that human civilization has been working for the latest half a century and still has work to do.


Why was this comment downvoted? Was it blatantly wrong and too conspiracy-ish, or did I miss anything?


Well, the obvious answer is that it sounds like the product of mental illness, which is a) not something that we want to encourage people to shoot back at and b) can't really lead to good conversation.


The only mental illness I suffer from is a propensity for C# and .NET... even though I know better. ;)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hi8jMRMsEJo#t=1114

http://i.imgur.com/1ry8whI.jpg


The original comment was a joke, then? Because these are really the only two contexts it can be parsed with.

I took a look at your brief comment history. The amount of feedback you're going to get here will be increasingly limited as your comments won't even be visible to most users. So this could be the only opportunity to address you:

You might have a serious problem without realizing it. Please, if it hasn't been already, get it checked out.


I hope it didn't come across as me trying to diagnose you, because I obviously don't even know you well enough to say you have a cold. It's just, devoid of context, there's a really high chance that comment that sounds like that is a product of mental illness, and that's why people are prone to downvote them.


I think a look at his comment history will give you the answer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: